Cargill Risk Model

The risk management function in the SMEs or the large trading company requires a concentrate of competences, both «classic financial» related to risk aspects of the market, and an understanding of  the risk dimensions of physical trading.

In a commodities trading operation the role of risk manager consists primarily to control the application of rules and risk limitation approved by the BOD and, if need be, of informing the latter of any violation.

The role also extends to supporting decision- making in trading, through analysis and supervision of objectives, while endeavoring to secure the value of transactions.

On a daily basis the risk manager and his team are in constant contact with the
various departments in order to compile the information needed to analyze the non-covered risks.

The risk manager concentrates especially on the market risk, risk of liquidity, basis risk, currency risk etc.) along with other types of risk associated with international trading such as risks of compensation (political / financial / banking) or “operational” risks associated with physical commodities (shipping/credit).

He or she thus organizes the risk monitoring of the operations with a view to allowing him or her to decide whether or not to set up a cover strategy by the conclusion of limiting the exposure depending on the risks the company is prepared to take, as defined in a hedging policy.


The “American model” might be worth studying for those “fancying the risk model”.


cargill risk management 8 stesp to building an effective hedging practice.png

Cargill, a very clean company, basis of the industry, (L’Université genevoise du trading) is arch-structured, it’s an army.

When Cargill does something, it’s not thoughtless. Their traders are marked with the panties. As soon as a position is taken, it has entered the system, there are automatic stop-losses, and an army of risk managers who monitor the traders and evaluate the positions.

There is a limit to the amount of business that a trader  can do with a counterpart and when a trader if out of bounds due to market fluctuations, you are encouraged to reduce exposure as much as possible. It reduces the amount of bad debt. Especially for emerging countries where you do not know the customers well.

This constrasts with the hedge fund or the”losing, betting double” trading firm.

The U.S company has also chosen between money made in a dirty way versus building a bona fide sustainable.

(Even so… it doesn’t traders cannot cut corners for margins and crush others when motivated).

Cargill’s culture presents  some disadvantages for petroleum “trading”. The bonuses are lower than in the competition, trading in crude oil is prohibited and individual risk-taking isn’t well appreciated.

Many times whole teams have gone to Vitol or Trafigura.

But the advantage of this prudence is that Cargill has a resistance to any event to the vagaries of the market.


Simon Jacques,

Commodity trading and finance


Simon is a certified Energy Risk Professional, “the gold standard of Energy Markets” as distinguished by the prestigious Global Association of Risk Professionals.

Simon Jacques +1-226-348-5610

Commodity trading and finance.

Advisor to Producers, processors and the end-users in North America


One thought on “Cargill Risk Model

  1. Pingback: Cargill vs “The Others” | Navigating the Commodity Markets with Freight and Spreads

Leave your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s